Managing a Broody Hen
Managing a Broody Hen
One of the most fascinating experiences of raising a backyard flock of hens can also be the most frustrating.
Every once in a while, a hen acts strangely. She fluffs her feathers, changes her clucking pitch, stops laying, and spends almost all her time in the nest. Reach in to retrieve eggs from under her and she’ll enthusiastically scold and probably give fingers a good peck.
She’s broody!
Broodiness is a natural bird instinct. Until artificial incubators came along in the late 1800s all baby chicks were brooded by a live hen. Farmers would prepare rows of nests filled with broody hens to ensure plenty of chicks for future chicken dinners and plentiful eggs. Over the years breeders have reduced broodiness in many chicken breeds and hybrids. Today nearly all chicks are hatched in modern incubators.

What Breeds Go Broody
The Hoover’s Hatchery catalog lists breeds that are likely or unlikely to become broody but the important word is “likely”. These are living creatures. There are always exceptions but generally the catalog’s advice is sound. It helps a customer predict the likelihood of broodiness in any breed or hybrid.
Some breeds like, Orpingtons, Cochins, Brahmas and other traditional heavy breed hens often go broody, but sometimes even white egg commercial strain hens choose motherhood. California Whites supposedly rarely go broody, but we’ve had a few be persistently broody and successfully raise babies.
Although broodiness is most common in the spring, sometimes hens opt for motherhood during the wrong season. We’ve had hens go broody in mid winter’s subzero cold. There’s no way babies can survive intense cold. Spring is the best season to let a broody hen contentedly enter motherhood.
The Downside of Broodiness and How to Discourage It
Here are some reasons why a flock owner might want to discourage a broody hen:
- Hens don’t lay when they are incubating eggs or raising babies. If lots of eggs are needed broody hens are a frustrating problem.
- Hens will go broody even if there’s no rooster in the coop. She will sit contentedly on infertile eggs for weeks and they’ll never hatch.
- It’s the wrong season for baby chicks.
When one of our hens goes broody and we need kitchen eggs but not baby chicks we put her in isolation. We have a large coop separated by a wire mesh wall. When a hen goes broody, we put her in one side that has no nests or cavities where she might sit. Usually after three or four days the broody tendency fades and we let her back into the flock. Soon she’ll be laying again. Anyone lacking a second coop could put a broody in a large cage with plenty of food and water but no nest.

The Upside of Broodiness
One of the most fascinating aspects of keeping chickens is watching a hen as she patiently incubates eggs and raises babies. It’s downright fun and is an inexpensive way to get new chicks for the flock. We have a rooster so our hen’s eggs are fertile and will hatch. In past years when we didn’t have a rooster we’d buy or swap eggs with a friend who has a rooster and put them under her. Fertile eggs can be ordered through the Internet.
When one of our hens goes broody and we want chicks we do these things:
- Put her in her own nest separated from other hens.
- Mark all the eggs we hope will hatch with pencilled “X” on their shells.
- Have chick starter feed, feeders and waterers ready for when the chicks hatch.
If all goes well after 21 days those eggs hatch and one proud new mother will introduce them to the world. She does the work keeping the babies warm and showing them food and water. We keep mom and chicks separate from the main flock until the babies are nearly full size.
No fertile eggs? Here’s a trick to enable a broody hen to raise babies.
- Separate her from the other hens and put a comfy nest in her new quarters.
- Put six or eight golf balls or artificial nest eggs in the nest. She’ll settle right down on them and keep them warm.
- After she’s been sitting for at least two weeks, buy six to ten chicks from a nearby farm store.
- Using a flashlight enter the coop after dark and remove the golf balls or nest eggs from under the hen. Replace them with the peeping babies.
Almost always Mom will readily adopt the new babies and proudly raise them.






